Largemouth bass fishing should be good. Many of the fish should be greater than 15 inches. Try fishing near felled trees, riprap embankments, and brush piles. Crappie fishing should be good, fishing tube jigs under a bobber anywhere from the south jetty up to the north jetty in late March and early April. Fish around submerged trees during summer months, and closer to the bank again when temperatures begin to cool in the fall. Most of the fish will be around 8.5 inches with a few greater than 10 inches. Bluegill can be caught all year with worms or small jigs. They are very numerous and will be 4 to 6 inches in length with some over 7. Redear sunfish fishing should be fair. Most of the fish will be around 9 inches with some over 10 inches. Fishing for channel catfish should be good, using prepared baits at the jetties and fishing dock. Spring sampling showed most Channel catfish between 16 to 20 inches in length. The channel catfish population is maintained by regular stocking by the Department of Conservation.
There are several regulations in place that will lessen the chances of an accidental introduction of zebra mussels into Blind Pony Lake. Zebra mussels are an invasive species that have caused numerous problems in other states and would be very disruptive for the hatchery if they were introduced into Blind Pony Lake. Private boats are prohibited on this lake; boats and oars for use on the lake are provided free of charge on a first come, first served basis, and anglers may use their own electric trolling motors on MDC boats. Anglers will be required to supply their own flotation devices. In addition, bait transported or held in containers with water is prohibited.